Airbnb vs Hostels vs Hotels vs Couchsurfing

image
15 Sept 2018: I've redesigned this site - there might be some bugs on how it displays/looks. Give me a few days to go over every page!
Share Link

What do you want to do?

Share a link to your friends, or visit my profile on social networking sites?

Click to share this page:
   
Or click to visit my profiles:
   

About me

Hi! Welcome to Complete City Guides!

Complete City Guides mascot logo

My name is Patrick, I'm originally from Sydney (Australia) but grew up in England (my second home) - and I love exploring cities (and writing about it!)

I work online in marketing, which gives me the opportunity to travel around the world full time.

So while I am away, I keep this blog updated with full travel info. I tend to stay in a city for a few months at a time, to really get to know it - then I write guides on it.

Popular Posts
Complete Guide to Planning a Thailand Trip! Places to visit, What to do, and Travel Tips for Thailand

Accommodation Options: Airbnb vs Hostels vs Hotels vs Couchsurfing

When going abroad you are often faced with the issue of finding accomodation. One of the most popular questions is Hostels vs Hotels. Do you want luxury, comfort, and peace and quiet (then hotel!). Or do you want cheap prices, socialable places that might be a bit busy (hostels!).

Of course that is over simplying the question of hostels vs hotels. There are actually four or five main options when it comes to deciding on accommodation in most cities.

  • Airbnb/Complete Apartment Rental - where you can rent entire apartments or rent just a room
  • Hostels - where you often stay in a shared dorm (although private rooms are in some hostels)
  • Hotels - the classic accomodation option, they range from cheap and cheerful 1 star dumps to 5 star buildings of luxury.
  • Couchsurfing - find a sofa or couch to crash on, in a strangers house. Safer and more fun than it sounds... (See our guide How to meet people on Couchsurfing too!)
  • and of course staying a friends house. But I'm ignoring this and focusing more on the airbnb vs hostels vs hotels vs couchsurfing options.

Of course renting an apartment isn't limited to just Airbnb, but since Airbnb has taken off it seems anyone who rents an apartment for a trip does it via Airbnb. Also, a fifth option exists which is staying with friends, but unless your friends are spread all over the globe this isn't a realistic option most times!

Airbnb for renting apartments or rooms. Get exactly what you want, often at a cheap price

Airbnb compared

Airbnb is a new company (founded in 2008) and seems to have completely taken over the whole renting apartment market. Whenever I rent an apartment, I will check only Airbnb (and I know of many other people who do the same).

They have two types of rentals available:

  • Rent a whole apartment - you have the whole apartment to yourself.
  • Rent a room - you get your own private room (you will often share the bathroom). In most cases the other people in the apartment/building will be the owners of the house. They just rent out a spare room from time to time.
Advantages of using Airbnb
  • You can see photos of the exact apartment (/room) you will be staying in. In a hotel you might be in the smallest rooms in the building, with no view, and lots of street noise.
  • The hosts are often friendly and there to help and advise you. I have had a host sit down for almost 30 minutes with a tourist map to explain what I could do in the city.
  • You can get a real kitchen to do real cooking. This can save a lot of money if you cook in a kitchen as opposed to eating in restaurants for every meal.
  • It is often cheaper than booking hotel rooms, especially if you are a bigger group.
Disadvantages of using Airbnb
  • There are some scammers on Airbnb (I've never encountered anyone personally who has been scammed, but have read about stories on the internet).
  • The photos might make the apartment look much better than it really is. See this Quora post for an example. I have been surprised by the size of apartments a few times - both because in real life it was much bigger and better than the photos made it seem, and unfortunately a few times where it was much smaller and not as nice as the photos made it look.
  • The people renting out to you (the hosts) are not really a business. If you have a major problem you can call Airbnb, but you never know if you are going to turn up and your host is a bit crazy...
  • Want more disadvantages? Check out this site.

Hostels sharing a dorm. Less privacy, but much more sociable

Hostels compared with Hotels

If you have never stayed in a hostel then you are probably imagining a run down, awful, smelly place full of people in bunk beds. Some are like that (5% maybe!). But as long as you check reviews you can avoid the worse hostels.

Hostels are great for meeting people. I would pick staying in a hostel rather than a hotel any day! People are in hostels to socalise (and save a bit of money!). Lots of hostels have bars, common rooms, they organise day trips, pub crawls etc.

Some of the hostels (I would say the top 15% - and it is easy to check reviews on sites like Hostel World, and any decent hostel will have lots and lots of reviews) will be as high quality as a great hotel (just with dorm rooms instead of private rooms).

Also a lot of hostels have private rooms (from 1 - 4 beds) with an ensuite bathroom. So you can get all the advantages and social aspects of a hostel without sharing a room with strangers.

Advantages staying in a hostel vs hotel, airbnb, couchsurfing

Hostels have bunk beds, Hotels have real beds!
  • It is really cheap (although in some cities, especially around special dates in the year, it can be cheaper to book an apartment on Airbnb or a hotel room if there is more than just one person in your group!)
  • It is super sociable - you will always meet friendly people. This is a huge advantage if you are travelling solo, but even if you are going as a group it can be fun to meet other people to hang out with.
  • They often organise day trips/activities - and they are often activities you would not be able to organise from a hotel. A lot of hostels (and all hostels that call themselves 'party hostels') will run a pub crawl at least a few times a night (often every night). They will take you to what they believe (or what pub/club pays them the most...) the best bars and clubs in the city. Even if the pub crawl route isn't the best (some can be really bad!) they are always fun because you are drinking with a group of like minded people.
  • The staff are very knowledgable of the city - much more than an Airbnb host or a regular hotel receptionist. They deal with questions every day from young travellers, and will often be more than happy to sit down with you to help you plan your time in the city.
Disadvantages of staying in a hostel
  • You share a room with strangers (of course you can get a private room!). This means noisy people, people returning late at night, people waking early in the morning and waking you up...
  • Security is never as good as a hotel. I've seen people leave laptops out, phones charging while they go out of the room and it is rare for things to get stolen, but it definitely happens! Lockers are often provided, but they can easily be pulled apart (they aren't often very secure, sometimes made of wood, I've even seen some that had no back panel so you could just drag the whole locker unit away from the wall to get access to everyones stuff...
  • They are often full of a younger crowd that likes drinking - this may be an advantage or a disadvantage, depending on what you are looking for. If you avoid the party hostels though, this isn't such a big problem.

Hotels the classic travel option. Often decent enough, but not very socialable

Hotel bed

Everyone knows what hotels are, and how they work. You pay a high price, get a private room. Hotels range from cheap 1 star places (you will probably have a nicer time in a hostel!) to luxurious 5 star hotels.

Advantages of staying in a hotel
Hotel Swimming pool
  • It will (probably) be high quality and if you have any problems you can speak to the hotel manager
  • If you are staying in an expensive hotel then nothing can beat a concierge who knows the city.
  • They often have other facilities, such as swimming pools or gyms.
  • And they also often can provide high quality meals (at a high price, though!)
Disadvantages of staying in a hotel
Nice Hotel bed
  • Cost - it can be cheaper in a hostel or even an Airbnb apartment.
  • They are not very socialable - if you are travelling by yourself this can be a big reason to avoid hotels
  • It might look great in the photos, but you might get the tiniest room with no view - at least with Airbnb you know exactly where you are going to be!

Couchsurfing stay with strangers. Can be really sociable and a fun experience, but it could be awful too!

Couchsurfing Logo

Couchsurfing is going to be the hardest one to explain to your friends (and even more difficult to explain to your parents, if you are younger).

Basically it works like this:

  • You are a 'surfer' (you want to sleep at other peoples houses). So you go on Couchsurfing.com's website and search for the city you are going to visit.
  • Then you contact 'hosts', asking to stay at their house.
    • Tip: it is a 'numbers game' - you will often have to send many requests to hosts
  • Eventually, a 'host' might accept you for the dates you requested.
  • Then you arrange with them to turn up (or maybe they will meet you at a train station etc).
  • They will show you where you will sleep (it can range from the floor, a sofa/couch (hence the name), to a spare bedroom).
  • Some hosts will give their guests (the 'surfers') keys and let them do their own thing. Some hosts will hang out and show their guests the city. It really depends on the person. There are no firm rules.
  • Throughout all of this, no money is exchanged.
    • Couchsurfing does try to get you to pay for verified status, but it isn't really worth it. It is more important to get 'references' from people, to prove you are a genuine and trustworthy person

Also see our guide on how to meet people on Couchsurfing!

Advantages of using Couchsurfing

  • It is free - but this shouldn't be your main reason for using Couchsurfing!
  • You get to meet a local in the city - they will often (but not always!) show you around the city, you will see how locals really live.
  • It can be really fun and you might make a friend for life. But you could also say bye at the end of your stay and never speak to them again!
Disadvantages of using Couchsurfing
  • You don't really know where you are staying
  • There is no guarantee of safety or security - you could be in a house with 10 other people, they could have a wild party while you are there, all your posessions could be stolen.
  • There are lots of Couchsurfing nightmares

Although I have to be honest, the worst I have ever encountered when meeting people through Couchsurfing (or swapping stories about people's worst CS experiences) was mostly smelly guests or bad hygiene issues. But, always be safe and cautious when using Couchsurfing.

So, which is best? Hotels vs Hostels, Airbnb, Couchsurfing?

Of course it really depends on many things, including what the city you are visiting is like in terms of hotel/hostel selection, on how much you have to spend (or want to spend), if you want to meet people (in hostels it is easy) etc.

  • If you are young (or feel young) and want to be sociable: Hostel
  • If you want to cook your own meals, with privacy: Airbnb
  • If you want to save money: Hostel
  • If you want to have some luxury: Hotel
  • If you want to sleep at a strangers house (maybe get involved in their life and live like a local): Couchsurfing.

Let me know what you think in the comments below...!

Date Posted
June 16th 2017
Tags 
Want To Know Best Travel Tips and Secret Gems? Read On...

Want to get the latest travel ideas, tips and advice straight in your email inbox?

Use Pinterest? Share this post:

Airbnb vs Hostels vs Hotels vs Couchsurfing

Complete City Guides

Hi! I'm Patrick! I love travelling, and has been travelling most of the year for over 10 years now. Now I share my trips, tricks and advice here on CompleteCityGuides.com.

Follow me on Twitter, Facebook or Instagram for more updates...

Comments (4)

Show/Post Comments

Next To Read:

Ultimate Guide to Safe Travelling! 35 Tips For Travelling Abroad Safely!
Ultimate Guide to Safe Travelling! 35 Tips For Travelling Abroad Safely!

The time you spend abroad on trips can be some of the best days of your life. However it can also go very bad, very quickly. There are many aspects to staying safe when abroad, but by being aware of them and thinking about them when you are on your trips you can try and avoid most problems. Here is a guide that covers everything you need to be aware of, to stay safe when abroad!

Posted: Thu 20th September, 2018

Best Shopping Malls in Bangkok - Which Shopping Malls To Not Miss Out On When Travelling To Bangkok
Best Shopping Malls in Bangkok - Which Shopping Malls To Not Miss Out On When Travelling To Bangkok

Bangkok is famous for its huge shopping malls. Here is a guide to what ones to make sure you visit when you are in Bangkok

Posted: Wed 1st August, 2018

Bangkok

How To Use Couchsurfing To Meet People While Travelling
How To Use Couchsurfing To Meet People While Travelling

Couchsurfing is popular for travellers who want to sleep on someones couch (and for hosts who like meeting travellers on their couch!). But you can also use it if travelling and you want to meet up with people. It can be a great source of meetups and finding likeminded people to meet when travelling!

Posted: Fri 5th May, 2017

Top Facts About Minsk You Didn't Know
Top Facts About Minsk You Didn't Know

Minsk is a bit of a mystery to a lot of people. Some might struggle to place it on a map. But here are some interesting facts that you probably didn't know about this great city.

Posted: Thu 9th November, 2017

Minsk

Top 7 Things To Do in Minsk
Top 7 Things To Do in Minsk

Minsk is probably the only European capital city that is largely untouched by masses of tourists. It isn't a city full of attractions, but there are certainly enough things to see and do to keep you entertained for a few days. Here are the top 7 attractions and things to see and do in Minsk, Belarus.

Posted: Mon 15th January, 2018

Minsk

Elephant Nature Park - Ethically See Elephants in Chiang Mai (And What Really Goes On There)
Elephant Nature Park - Ethically See Elephants in Chiang Mai (And What Really Goes On There)

Thailand is famous for its elephant related tourist attractions. However many of these involve cruel training methods or cruel elephant rides. "Elephant Nature Park" in Chiang Mai is an elephant sanctuary that seems to really care about their elephants. Read on to find out about our trip to the Elephant Nature Park, and find out what we think of it and how they treat their animals

Posted: Fri 11th May, 2018

Chiang Mai

iamge
Top Travel Movies - 29 Movie Recommendations from the top travel bloggers!
Top Travel Movies - 29 Movie Recommendations from the top travel bloggers!

Get some inspiration for travel ideas, with these top movies about travelling and/or backpacking. Tell us in the comments below what your favourite travel movie...

66 Likes

15

Exploring The Thailand Monkey City of Lopburi (and how to get there from Bangkok)
Exploring The Thailand Monkey City of Lopburi (and how to get there from Bangkok)

Lopburi is Thailand's famous 'Monkey City'. The city is around 150km (93 miles) northeast of Bangkok, and is home to hundreds of macaque monkeys. It is a popula...

101 Likes

16

Top North American Destinations
Top North American Destinations

Want to find some awesome places to go and visit in North America? Read on! This guide has the best and popular places that North America has to offer. You coul...

137 Likes

16

Ultimate Packing List for Travel (Print this checklist out before packing for your next trip)
Ultimate Packing List for Travel (Print this checklist out before packing for your next trip)

Don't go away and realise you forgot something. Here is the ultimate packing list that covers everything you need to think about and remember, including all the...

17 Likes

15

About Me

I'm an Australian who has lived in Europe for most of my life. I work online, travelling with my laptop, working online and exploring cities for months at a time.

Read my blog